fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsThe Privilege of the Sword by Ellen KushnerThe Privilege of the Sword by Ellen Kushner

“Whatever the duke means to do with her, it can’t be anything decent.”

The Privilege of the Sword is Ellen Kushner’s sequel to her novel Swordspoint which was about the doings of the high and low societies in her fictional town of Riverside. The main characters of that novel were the nobleman Alec Tremontaine, a student, and his lover, the famous swordsman Richard St. Vier. You don’t need to read Swordspoint before reading The Privilege of the Sword, but it will probably be more enjoyable if you do because you’ll have some background on most of the characters.

Now Alec is known as the Mad Duke Tremontaine. He spends some of his time in his mansion outside the city, but he really prefers to reside in his house in Riverside where the common people live. The Mad Duke is known for being rapacious and decadent. Yet when he asks his estranged sister to send her 15-year-old daughter Katherine to him, Katherine must go because Alec controls the family fortune.

When Katherine goes to live with her mad uncle, she envisions beautiful new gowns, exciting balls, and gallant suitors. And indeed that’s probably what she would have gotten if this story hadn’t been written by Ellen Kushner. A sweet romantic fantasy isn’t what Kushner had in mind, however (though there is sweetness and romance). Instead, the Mad Duke dresses Katherine like a boy and makes her take swordfighting lessons. She hates this at first, but later she learns that her skills are quite useful for carrying out her romantic schemes. Even later it becomes clear that there’s a method to her uncle’s madness.

Katherine is a delightful character. At the beginning she’s a sweet romantic girl with starry visions and high hopes, but her innocence is challenged when she joins the lascivious duke’s household. She’s forced to grow over the course of the novel and she learns about friendship, honor, and her own (and other people’s) sexuality. Katherine’s friendship with Marcus, a boy who works for the duke, is sweet. However, her friendship with the noblewoman Artemesia, which drives the plot in the second half of the novel, is hard to believe in since two girls hardly know each other. I did like, however, how they were bound together by the romantic admiration for the same book.

fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsAlec is even more unlikeable in The Privilege of the Sword than he was in Swordspoint, but Kushner provides us with more of his backstory in this novel and he at least becomes a little more sympathetic. By the end I had decided that maybe I liked him after all. He has no respect for the rules of his society and it’s hard not to admire him for that. Readers of Swordspoint will also be interested to see what became of the famous swordsman Richard St. Vier.

The plot of The Privilege of the Sword is “lite” and a bit muddled. I found it somewhat dull at first, but it picks up eventually when the political intrigue starts and there’s a mystery for Katherine and Marcus to solve. The story isn’t particularly memorable, but it’s mostly amusing, unpredictable, and mercifully avoids all fantasy clichés. Most notably, it examines gender and sexuality issues in a way that has so far been unusual in fantasy literature. (Though I hesitate to call this novel a fantasy since its only fantastical element is the totally made-up setting.) Most of the characters are exploring their sexuality (which is both homosexual and heterosexual and gets rather decadent in parts) and this, in my opinion, affects the plot negatively. In other words, it could be argued that the book is more about sex than it is about story.

I listened to the audio version of The Privilege of the Sword which was produced by Neil Gaiman Presents and expertly narrated by Ellen Kushner and a full cast. Neil Gaiman and actress Felicia Day make vocal appearances. If you plan to read The Privilege of the Sword, you should consider the audiobook.

~Kat Hooper

The Privilege of the Sword The Privilege of the Sword by Ellen KushnerMy reactions to Ellen Kushner’s The Privilege of the Sword mirror Kat’s almost exactly, and I have some thoughts about why the story unfolds the way it does. Like Kat, I enjoyed Katherine, the young protagonist. I like Katherine’s relationship with her mother and her almost unconscious sense that she, the only girl in her family, is responsible for holding things together, which, as the story opens, she is. Katherine is smart and practical but she is a girl (and of noble family) in her society, so I believed it when, for example, Katherine is horrified the first time she is made to dress in men’s clothing. I liked her naivete and the way she grows throughout the book.

It seems like the entire first half of the book is stage-setting (I’m using that term deliberately) for a slow-burning plot that kicks into high gear only about fifty pages from the end. A large part of that is Katherine learning sword-fighting and the ways of the city … and the readers being re-introduced to her uncle, Alec Campion, now the Mad Duke. He is just as neurotic as ever, only now he has money and power. I enjoyed Katherine’s growing relationship with Marcus. Like Kat, I found the instant friendship with shallow, sheltered Artimesia implausible. First of all, the two girls barely meet; secondly, Katherine reaches out to Artimesia for help and Artimesia laughs at her. Yet, months later, Katherine is willing to go to great risk to help “her friend.”

The book is episodic, and I think that slows it down and makes some parts even a little boring. The Privilege of the Sword was published before Serial Box began publishing Tremontaine, but I am going to speculate that some sense of a larger, shared fictional world was in the back of Kushner’s mind as she wrote this, which is why we get subplots that introduce completely different characters, and take us so far away from Katherine and The Mad Duke.

And there were things I loved. I enjoy this world and spending time in it. I loved the cheesy novel that the girls bond over, and I love the sense of theater that permeates the book; there is a play made of the book; Marcus and Katherine spy on two lovers from outside the window, and those scenes play out like a pantomime; later they spy on someone in a brothel to the exact same effect. Alec Campion’s behavior is about ninety percent theater, only he knows it. This is a marked contrast to the oblivious nobles who think they live lives of virtue and honesty when ninety percent of what they do is theater as well. It’s no accident that, as Artimesia’s parents are forcing her into a marriage to a rapist, her mother is decking her out like a fashion doll. The Mad Duke is unpopular and considered mad in large part because he calls out the pretense and hypocrisy of the noble lifestyle. The story is filled with themes of disguise, masks, costumes and appearance over truth.

I liked innocent Katherine’s wry sense of humor. In one scene, she walks into her uncle’s chamber where fifteen naked people are sleeping off an orgy. Katherine notes that now she knows that the statues in the sculpture garden are anatomically correct.

I also liked what the story has to say about equality and about sexual violence. Artimesia is sheltered and because of that she does a foolish thing, and faces terrible consequences. When she turns to her family, the people who are supposed to protect her, they ignore her. The whole point of Alec training up his niece to be a “swordsman” comes into focus, because the Mad Duke lives to upend the hypocritical social mores of his society. I loved all of that, and I loved that play. That all said, I found the ending less than believable, and I think it was set up only to allow a graceful exit for two powerful characters. I could hear the plot-structure creaking a bit in the background.

Still, I liked The Privilege of the Sword the way I might like a comfortable chair, even if the upholstery is fraying, or a worn old quilt. It took me back to a place I enjoy and introduced me to some characters I liked. I enjoyed my second visit to Riverside.

~Marion Deeds

Welcome to Riverside, where the aristocratic and the ambitious battle for power in the city’s ballroom, brothels and boudoirs. Into this alluring world walks Katherine, a well-bred country girl versed in the rules of conventional society. Her mistake is thinking that they apply. For Katherine’s host and uncle, Alec Campion, aka the Mad Duke Tremontaine, is in charge here—and to him, rules are made to be broken. When Alec decides it would be more amusing for his niece to learn swordplay than to follow the usual path to marriage, her world changes forever. Blade in hand, it’s up to Katherine to navigate a maze of secrets and scoundrels and to gain the self-discovery that comes to those who master: the privilege of the sword.

Ellen Kushner Riverside 1. Swordspoint 2. The Tale of the Kings 3. The Privilege of the Sword Thomas the Rhymer Ellen Kushner Riverside 1. Swordspoint 2. The Tale of the Kings 3. The Privilege of the Sword Thomas the Rhymer Ellen Kushner Riverside 1. Swordspoint 2. The Tale of the Kings 3. The Privilege of the Sword Thomas the Rhymer


  • Kat Hooper

    KAT HOOPER, who started this site in June 2007, earned a Ph.D. in neuroscience and psychology at Indiana University (Bloomington) and now teaches and conducts brain research at the University of North Florida. When she reads fiction, she wants to encounter new ideas and lots of imagination. She wants to view the world in a different way. She wants to have her mind blown. She loves beautiful language and has no patience for dull prose, vapid romance, or cheesy dialogue. She prefers complex characterization, intriguing plots, and plenty of action. Favorite authors are Jack Vance, Robin Hobb, Kage Baker, William Gibson, Gene Wolfe, Richard Matheson, and C.S. Lewis.

    View all posts
  • Marion Deeds

    Marion Deeds, with us since March, 2011, is the author of the fantasy novella ALUMINUM LEAVES. Her short fiction has appeared in the anthologies BEYOND THE STARS, THE WAND THAT ROCKS THE CRADLE, STRANGE CALIFORNIA, and in Podcastle, The Noyo River Review, Daily Science Fiction and Flash Fiction Online. She’s retired from 35 years in county government, and spends some of her free time volunteering at a second-hand bookstore in her home town.

    View all posts