fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsInside a Silver Box by Walter Mosley science fiction book reviewsInside a Silver Box by Walter Mosley

Sometimes you read a book and think, “Well, that was a bad book.” And sometimes you read a book and wonder, “Was that a bad book?” Walter Mosley has been a widely praised author for decades, has won a host of major awards, and is known for his sharp characterization and compelling plotting. So when I read a book of his that just throws me wholly for a loop, one in which I can’t abide either the characters or plot at all, so much so that I have to force myself to reach the halfway point before finally giving up, I have to wonder, “Was that a bad book, or did I miss something?”

Inside a Silver Box offers up an all-powerful being/machine — the titular silver box — whose goal is to stop the last of a genocidal alien race from regaining control of the box (it had been the aliens’ super-weapon) and using it to wipe out an entire species yet again. The box, which ended up buried under Central Park, will go so far as to destroy the Earth if needed to stop the Laz. Before things come to that point, it turns to two human tools, Lorraine and Robbie, who “met” when Robbie raped and murdered Lorraine. Thanks to the god-like power of the box, Lorraine is resurrected, each of them gains a portion of the other, and then they are “augmented” so as to better be able to deal with the Laz. And that’s as far as I got.

OK, let’s face it. An author doesn’t choose to make a protagonist be a rapist/murderer accidentally, so there is something Mosley is trying to do here with Ronnie’s character. But personally, I just couldn’t buy into it. Maybe over some time (a lot of time) I could be brought over, not into forgiveness (which I don’t want to intimate Mosley is going for here) but into at least sticking with the character a ways. But when the woman who was just raped and beaten to death is only a few pages later willingly having sex with the rapist who also killed her, it’s just a bit too much too soon (even rationally accepting the whole it isn’t fully “her” that’s doing it).

So that was one sticking point. A very big sticking point. Generally though, everything in Inside a Silver Box comes way too fast. And randomly. It’s all a bit of a jumble, too arbitrary, with little sense of relation or narrative or characterization. Lorraine and Ronnie spin one way then the other, as does the plot, with no consistency that I could see. Dialogue rarely felt authentic and also felt inconsistent. Descriptive detail is almost entirely lacking (making me wonder at times if things were happening in a total vacuum). And stylistically the prose ranged from mediocre to flat.

Is it bad? Or is that Mosley isn’t telling a narrative in the usual novelistic sense, but is instead not bothering with real characters or plot or stylistic flourishes in order to tell more of a fable so as to explore questions of existence, compassion, class, race, etc.? It’s possible. But to be honest, an author has to bring me along at least part way via storytelling craft to get me to consider the questions he/she wants to raise, and from my perspective, Mosley didn’t succeed. So is Inside a Silver Box a bad book? Maybe I did just miss something, but for me, it was nearly unreadable.

Publication Date: January 27, 2015. Walter Mosley’s talent knows no bounds. Inside a Silver Box continues to explore the cosmic questions entertainingly discussed in his Crosstown to Oblivion. From life’s meaning to the nature of good and evil, Mosley takes readers on a speculative journey beyond reality. In Inside a Silver Box, two people brought together by a horrific act are united in a common cause by the powers of the Silver Box. The two join to protect humanity from destruction by an alien race, the Laz, hell-bent on regaining control over the Silver Box, the most destructive and powerful tool in the universe. The Silver Box will stop at nothing to prevent its former master from returning to being, even if it means finishing the earth itself.


  • Bill Capossere

    BILL CAPOSSERE, who's been with us since June 2007, lives in Rochester NY, where he is an English adjunct by day and a writer by night. His essays and stories have appeared in Colorado Review, Rosebud, Alaska Quarterly, and other literary journals, along with a few anthologies, and been recognized in the "Notable Essays" section of Best American Essays. His children's work has appeared in several magazines, while his plays have been given stage readings at GEVA Theatre and Bristol Valley Playhouse. When he's not writing, reading, reviewing, or teaching, he can usually be found with his wife and son on the frisbee golf course or the ultimate frisbee field.

    View all posts