fantasy book review Charles de Lint Eyes Like LeavesEyes Like Leaves by Charles de Lint

fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsThe magic is leaving the Green Isles. The Summerlord Hafarl’s staff has been broken, and the Everwinter is coming to blanket the islands in snow forever. To make matters worse, the Vikings are raiding up and down the shore, laying waste to everything in their way. It’s up to Puretongue, leader of the dhruides, to weld together the last scraps of the Summerlord’s power that can be found in the people to create a defense against Lothan, and bring summer and magic back to the isles.

Eyes Like Leaves is well-paced, and the action scenes flash with energy. Charles de Lint shows signs of the bardic gift in his ability to make scenes come alive, especially the chase scene with the direwolves pursuing the tinker caravan.

While the characters are interesting and detailed, and individual scenes are beautifully written, the plot is oddly flat and lacks originality. This feels like a too-literal retelling of classical Irish mythology, without enough innovation to be fresh or exciting. It seems a little too scripted, with each character arriving just when needed, and advancing the plot in exactly the right direction. While terrible things do happen, there is not a great sense of tension — just a sense of inevitability.

This book proves to me that talent is not the sole ingredient of success. Eyes Like Leaves is well-written, but I never actually cared about the story. I never felt emotionally connected to the characters. While there is nothing overtly bad about the story, there is little here to merit recommending it above all the other quest fantasy novels that have been published.

Eyes Like Leaves is actually one of the first books Charles de Lint wrote, but it has never before been published. His editor told him that having published two secondary world fantasy novels, and one urban novel, that the next novel he published would pigeonhole him. He put this manuscript on the shelf and published Yarrow instead, putting his feet firmly on the urban fantasy path, a decision that I, and legions of his other fans, are grateful for. He recently reworked Eyes Like Leaves and released it for publication. This is obviously not de Lint at his peak, but there are the glimmers of greatness here that he has realized in his later works. I would recommend this book for fans of Irish mythology and de Lint completionists.

~Ruth Arnell

fantasy book reviews science fiction book reviewsfantasy book review Charles de Lint Eyes Like LeavesCharles de Lint wrote Eyes Like Leaves in 1980, but he didn’t publish it then. In 1980, he explains in the foreword, he had written two “alternate world” stories and one contemporary fantasy; de Lint thought that a third alternate world fantasy would typecast him, and he didn’t want to be restricted. Thus the book languished for thirty years before being brought out.

The cover on the Advanced Reader Copy I read features a regal, red-haired, antlered woman, wearing an oak-leaf mask, a fox at her feet. It has almost nothing to do with the book (except perhaps the leaves) but it is gorgeous and inviting and I hope that Tachyon Press doesn’t change a thing.

In Eyes Like Leaves, the land of the Green Isles is under double assault. The yellow-haired Saramand and their warships have come a-viking, and this time they plan to colonize, while winter creeps steadily down from the north. Strange demons and beasts roam the night. This is because Hafarl and Lothan, sons of the Horned God and the Lady, are locked in a struggle, and Lothan is winning. Hafarl rules the spring and summer while Lothan is the winter lord, but Lothan intends to rule the green isles year round. In their battle, Lothan broke Hafarl’s staff, the symbol of his power, weakening him. Now a handful of humans with green magic must make their way to the heart of winter and help the Summer Lord regain the balance.

This backstory flows out over time, but de Lint pitches us straight into the action, as Tarn, a wizard in training, battles a “stormkin,” one of Lothan’s monsters. Tarn was an orphan boy who was taken in by a dhruide or tree-mage, Puretongue. Tarn learned quickly but Puretongue left before his lessons were complete, called away by a vision. He charges Tarn to find a particular person with green magic. This person will be vital to the Summer Lord.

Later Tarn finds the person: a frail, red-haired young woman named Carrie, who is in the company of a family of tinkers. A Saramand raid left Carrie an orphan and a refugee. Raised in a different religious tradition, Carrie finds wizards and magic frightening and has no idea of the sheer power of her own magic. Before Tarn can win her over, the tinkers are beset by the stormkin.

Puretongue, meanwhile, has located Deren, another person with magic. They head north. A harper on board their ship tells Puretongue about a dream he’s had, about three runes. Plainly the three runes directly relate to the way to defeat Lothan, but Puretongue doesn’t understand how.

The book is written in a mosaic style with shifting points of view, dipping into the minds of the various pilgrims, even Lothan and Lothan’s primary minion, the Captain. The primary story here, though, is Tarn’s. Tarn feels that he has always fallen short. The abandonment by his parents left a deep wound and he must battle his pride as well as blizzards and stormkin at every step of his quest. Of course there is more to his story and the information that Puretongue reveals midway through the book plunges Tarn into a downward spiral.

Carrie has a lot of aspects of a certain type of female character that showed up a lot in 1970s and 1980s fantasy. She has deep and powerful magic but is nearly unconscious of it. Consciously, Carrie frequently frets and worries that she isn’t strong enough and can’t do what’s needed, while she intuitively does the right thing. Apparently red-haired big-eyed waifs can’t consciously wield their own power, because this makes them too scary. De Lint also falls short of delivering a real conflict between Carrie’s power and her belief. Carrie is a less successful character than Tarn mostly for these reasons.

The magical system here is old-school, with a nice use of standing stones and ley lines as convenient power stations for the wizards. One sequence in the last third of the book reminded me, jarringly, of the first Star Wars movie, when there is a “massive disturbance in the force.” The event is supported by de Lint’s magic, but just goes on too long.

Shifting points of view make for a very choppy read at times, especially when de Lint throws in italicized flashbacks. Seeing how rough the technique is, I was reminded how much de Lint has perfected the mosaic technique in later books.

As always, though, de Lint’s story is filled with music, elegant prose and clever turns of phrase. Here is some music around a tinker campfire:

Kinn tucked his fiddle under his chin and began another tune. Fenne plucked a strange harmony on her cittern that, by all rights, should not have fit for the old tune Kinn drew from his strings, but its notes slipped snugly into all the right places just the same.

In the forward, de Lint says that although he went through the manuscripts and made grammar changes, he did not change the plot. I enjoyed the book and I think the classic Good versus Evil plot still holds up, but Eyes Like Leaves is most interesting as a look back at a gifted writer’s beginnings.

~Marion Deeds

Eyes Like Leaves — (2009) Publisher: Magic is already fading in the Green Isles, but it’s still a time when myths walk the world and the children of the ancient gods are engaged in one final confrontation. But when legendary creatures wage war, it s the ordinary people who suffer the consequences — unless they, themselves, can find a way to bring an end to the hostilities. The trouble is, not all of them are able to pick a side. Eyes Like Leaves was written in the days of Moonheart and Charles de Lint’s other high fantasy novels. The tale slept like a long-forgotten lover until he recently chose torevisit (and polish) this never-before-published gem.


  • Ruth Arnell

    RUTH ARNELL (on FanLit's staff January 2009 — August 2013) earned a Ph.D. in political science and is a college professor in Idaho. From a young age she has maxed out her library card the way some people do credit cards. Ruth started reading fantasy with A Wrinkle in Time and The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe — books that still occupy an honored spot on her bookshelf today. Ruth and her husband have a young son, but their house is actually presided over by a flame-point Siamese who answers, sometimes, to the name of Griffon.

  • Marion Deeds

    Marion Deeds, with us since March, 2011, is the author of the fantasy novella ALUMINUM LEAVES. Her short fiction has appeared in the anthologies BEYOND THE STARS, THE WAND THAT ROCKS THE CRADLE, STRANGE CALIFORNIA, and in Podcastle, The Noyo River Review, Daily Science Fiction and Flash Fiction Online. She’s retired from 35 years in county government, and spends some of her free time volunteering at a second-hand bookstore in her home town.