Thief Eyes: Different opinions

Thief Eyes by Janni Lee Simner

Based on the Icelandic myth told in Njal’s Saga, Thief Eyes by Janni Lee Simner centers around American teenager Haley, who comes to Iceland with her father. The two of them are trying to find Haley’s mother, who had disappeared there a year earlier after an argument with Haley’s dad. Haley gets caught up in a generations-old curse when she finds an inscribed coin on the shore of a lake. Trying to escape the effects of the curse, she has to face the consequences of actions made by people a thousand years before she was born, and negotiate the conflicting needs of her parents, ancient gods, and Ari, a young man who is much more than he seems.

I was impressed with the originality of the setting. Based on ancient Icelandic mythology, this story is in keeping with many recent young adult fantasy books also based on mythological settings, but mines new territory rather than the more utilized Celtic or Greek mythologies. However, the Icelandic myth felt only loosely attached to the story, which instead focused on angsty teenage melodrama and dysfunctional family relationships. The story was at its best when it focused on the saga elements, especially when Haley and Hallgerd finally confront each other at the end, but tended to meander through the rest of the setting with little purpose. The characters — Haley, Ari, and the adults — all felt like stock clichés rather than characters that evolved on any level.

As in her previous work, Bones of Faerie, Simner excels at creating interesting settings, but struggles with characterization. Capable of writing compelling scenes, her skills falter when it comes to linking those scenes together into an evocative story. While the climax was compelling, the payoff was not worth the investment of reading the rest of the book.

~Ruth Arnell

Thief Eyes begins with a spine-tingling scene of sorcery, in which Hallgerd, a young girl in ancient Iceland, calls upon dangerous powers in order to avoid an unwanted marriage. With this scene, Janni Lee Simner sets an ominous mood, gives us some background information, and provides a few tantalizing hints about what might unfold later.

We move then to Haley, a young American girl of today who has just arrived in Iceland with her geologist father. A year ago, Haley’s mother went missing on the island, and she has accompanied her father in the hopes of finding out what happened. Uncanny events start to occur when she discovers a strange ancient coin, and then she learns in heartbreaking fashion that her family was not as happy as she thought it was.

Distraught, hounded by Hallgerd’s spirit, Haley takes a dangerous tumble into Iceland’s mythical, magical underside. Her quest is to keep Hallgerd’s spell from unleashing volcanic disaster. Her closest allies are Ari, a boy who is also descended from a powerful magical legacy, and Freki, an utterly adorable talking white fox (he’s supposed to be a wolf, he tells us, but there are no wolves in Iceland).

I really enjoyed the characterization in Thief Eyes. Every character is nuanced rather than “good” or “evil”; you never know when a “good guy” might make a mistake or a “bad guy” might surprise you by doing something honorable. Haley is a terrific heroine, a strong, bright girl who questions authority and doesn’t just do things because a supernatural figure tells her to. She faces temptations — both romantic and vengeful — but tries to do the right thing even when it isn’t easy.

The plot is complex, dealing with several timelines at once, and Simner brings it all together in a climactic scene that’s clever and touching. I also like the way the romantic subplot is handled at the end. It seems true to the characters’ ages and where they are in their lives.

Thief Eyes paints a vivid picture of Iceland and alludes to many of its myths. You may find yourself wanting to travel there or to read the classic sagas. I know I did! This is a well-researched and thoroughly enjoyable young adult novel, not to mention refreshingly original. (No vampires!)

~Kelly Lasiter