Kingdom of Exiles by S.B. Nova
Here we have the tale of Serena Smith, blacksmith’s daughter exiled from her puritan-like settlement and then kidnapped by fairies and sold in the Kingdom of Aldar, which has much worse political problems than the oppressive community from which she’s taken. The difference is, she finds a way of making a difference — a thing she could not do in her human home.
I feel like this kind of fairy story is a bit at war with itself. Kingdom of Exiles (2017) bills as a feminist tale and means to make Serena fierce and self-actualizing, but there are at least as many times when the story can’t be served by this kind of persona and it falls into sharp conflict with its own ideals. Women ought to be playing heroic roles, but human power is never as good as fairy power in this story. When humans are amplified with magic, we’re again, not talking about feminine power. What is it we’re meant to cheer for? Humans becoming less human? Also, the romance fetishizes the fae in their superior power and physique relative to humans and I just don’t know how I feel about that as a self-respecting humanoid.
S.B. Nova is constantly telling me about the profundity of people’s reactions and feelings instead of showing me. At times this felt forced and even sentimental. The fae are drawn up as an austere race compared with more sensitive humans, but we ultimately see so much fae emotional display without any of it feeling well earned.
Serena is sold into a military type of training camp for both fae and human captives. This kind of training ground is pretty common and it’s all right when well done, but it wasn’t in Kingdom of Exiles. I just couldn’t suspend disbelief. I’ve been in intense training environments and nothing about this world felt believable, down to details about food consumed. No one takes pastries into the mountains, people! They’re too heavy and they’ll be smashed in your backpack. Too many of the trials felt like kids’ scavenger hunts and when all characters took themselves so seriously, I couldn’t help myself from laughing aloud.
It’s possible this was diverting story for some readers, but I found it both contradictory and sentimental.
“… and I just don’t know how I feel about that as a self-respecting humanoid.”
Thanks for standing up for us humanoids everywhere, Taya! :)